You are not commenting on the fact that the Welsh are now largely in favour of independence. The spiritual dimension of all this is clearly lost on you. That’s a 6 point increase from January, and a massive 11 point increase since December last year. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. However, with the prospect of an Adam Price-led Plaid Cymru being the junior partners in a coalition government come next May, the time is now right to examine more closely the realities of what Welsh independence would mean. ; the UK has a trade deficit of £120 bn. In 2017/18, ONS data estimated the GDP of Wales to be £73.1 billion. What is clear is that those advocating Welsh independence struggle to answer even the most basic of questions as to how Wales would sustain itself economically, let alone prosper, yet this is seldom put under a spotlight by the Welsh media. It has played a big and helpful part in allowing people who believed in Welsh independence to discover each other and work together. But this is an unfair comparison, and quite the wrong one to make. Wales’s government deficit is, even at current levels, consistently higher than that of Greece during the Greek government-debt crisis. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. As Ifan says, we need to come together, not concentrate on microaggressions and extreme minoritarian issues that seek to divide us. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account. All you are doing is feeding into something that will resemble the troubles in Ireland and you will lose that game in the twenty-first century. Hall was close to Marc Clement of Swansea University. Economically we are in a better position to thrive out of the union than in the union – You can carry on with your disinformation for as long as you like – we are not listening to you. Those three I mentioned scream oppression and racism and diversity when the country they live in isn’t that diverse. In historic terms, most of the Welsh population has only been here five minutes. The period that followed saw a massive cultural shift at the WDA. PS the likes of Nia Naseem, Yasmin Begun and Aled and Teifi enhance the Welsh national movement. Alternatively, she could be a genuine subscriber called Joanne Davies. If you tap into the right networks, particular inside information will bubble to the surface very quickly. The politicisation of economic development has killed off any possibility of raising Wales’s GDP above 75% of the UK average. It’s the highest figure ever recorded in a poll – and eight points up from 2017. This doesn’t mean ignoring political issues which divide us but discussing them in a social and amicable manner. The onus is on the Welsh nationalists to explain how all the shortcomings outlined in this essay would be addressed. Forums also have their issues, and one of the early problems were the various ‘flame wars’ that erupted, every bit as nasty as those on Twitter now. People in Flintshire often spend a significant part of their working and social lives in Lancashire, Cheshire and Merseyside. – I rarely get anxious or triggered! Myth #4: We’re stronger together! It’s easy to forget that behind the words on the screen and little profile picture is a real human being on whom our words have a real effect. Let’s be generous and say that Wales exports 356 million cubic metres (356 billion litres) per year and compare it to the maths in this attached chart: Now let’s pretend Welsh nationalists get their way and the Welsh Government puts a huge levy on the extraction charge, say 50p per m3 = £178 million pa. But the opposition are not exactly a bunch of whiter than white angels. In response to Stuart Evans’s strangely confirmatory comment, offering the opportunity to show how correct Marcus Stead’s polemic is, in that Stead provides reputable sources for his data. In the end you will find absolute resistance with every initiative taken to destroy Wales and turn it into some second home county palatinate. Plaid Cymru councillors are often out on the doorstep or in events in their communities 52 weeks a year, having organic conversations with people, face to face. Twitter no doubt has its uses, particularly as a medium to follow the latest news on an issue. You must inhabit a parallel universe. I’ve even seen YesCymru Twitter accounts get into arguments with each other, which isn’t a good look for any movement. One poster claims that if Wales charged a market price of £0.003 per litre, that would amount to £642 million per year, which equates to £204.52 per Welsh citizen, per year. What one sees on Twitter however is the same 10-20 people falling out ad nauseam. This is unfortunately inherent to the medium. It was designed to deliver economic development to external customers. Wales isn’t actually that diverse apart from a couple of pockets in Cardiff, Newport and Swansea. Second, your twitter account is new , with a handful of followers and your posts are anti-Welsh. There’s no room to include polite social behaviour. close. A simple economic reality check for us in Wales . The shortfall can be explained by the deluge of English immigrants foisted upon us – who are increasingly viewed as subversive to the Welsh identity. Evans’ ill informed claim that ‘only 40% of the people living in Wales were born here.’ is clearly unsustainable when one is minded of the proven facts, in that the last British National Census of 2011 very clearly shows 72.66% of peoples currently living in Wales were born in Wales. Welsh nationalism (Welsh: Cenedlaetholdeb Cymreig) emphasises and celebrates the distinctiveness of Welsh language, culture, and history, and calls for more self-determination for Wales, which might include more devolved powers for the Senedd, or full independence from the United Kingdom Depending on which poster you go by, Wales exports 214 billion, 243 billion or 100 billion litres of water to England each year. – couldn’t be starker. It’s probably Royston Jones or a Propel member out to wind sensible people up. In 2021, concessions to Plaid Cymru may well include the devolution of broadcasting powers to Wales, and, at a push, the devolution of criminal justice powers. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. In addition, thousands of vehicles cross daily and seamlessly along the A48 between South Wales and the Midlands, while in north east wales, thousands of people in Flintshire and Denbighshire cross between Wales and England for work and recreation, and are to a large extent economically and culturally aligned with Cheshire, Merseyside and Lancashire. There would be a need to create a Welsh equivalent of the Foreign Office, and defence capabilities, plus lots more. When problematic views do exist in the mainstream, most people are simply ignorant of the issues and could be brought around over a cup of coffee. It is sheer poison. ( Log Out / For many decades, support for Welsh independence has fluctuated between about 12% and 25%. The WDA was not designed to service the Welsh Assembly Government. The danger of Welsh independence happening almost by default comes not through any great surge in support from the Welsh electorate, but through the outcome of next year’s Welsh Parliamentary elections, which, as things stand, will see a hard left Welsh Labour party favouring maximum devolution in coalition with Plaid Cymru, also of the hard left, committed to Welsh independence. This might be an inconvenient truth to some, but it is a truth nevertheless. Would it be paid for by an astronomical level of borrowing each and every year well into the future? The Welsh Government also plans to borrow £125 million and use revenue reserves of £125 million. A … There are 1001 different ways of defining minorities. Much more recently, former Panorama journalist Phil Parry exposed the close links between BBC Wales and Plaid Cymru. The figures supplied above strongly suggest that an independent Wales would fail the EU’s membership criteria for a functioning market economy. Myth Busted: We believe that independence for the people of Wales is central to a prosperous economy and society. The WDA was being steered by Economic Development Minister Andrew Davies, who also had close links to Swansea University. And the person receiving the message, rather than thinking ‘do I agree with this message’ interprets it as an attack on one’s own views and thinks ‘how do I point out the flaws in this argument’? The modern Welsh independence movement … More are warming to Welsh independence after witnessing Westminster’s management of Brexit and the COVID crisis. Do Reach Plc’s Welsh publications have a future. I agree. Here’s where their maths becomes very, very dodgy. By Teleri Glyn Jones BBC Wales News. Ownership of the water is in Government hands via the Environment Agency, and is devolved in Wales. Modern-day Welsh nationalism is at best based on naivety and trite sentiment, and at worst on the anti-English racism so often seen from its supporters on social media, based on grudges and fake grievances. Welsh ‘independence’ is not something that instinctively sits comfortably with most of the Welsh population. In March, one poll put support for Welsh independence at a record level of 39% – on a par with Scotland’s yes campaign before the 2014 referendum. It means that someone sharing content on Facebook is much more likely to reach a new audience than on Twitter. If people want genuine diversity then they need to embrace the most important diversity of all – diversity of opinion. The danger of Wales sleepwalking towards independence is altogether more subtle. But, such divisiveness and nastiness could easily demoralise and derail the independence movement from within so to speak. Hardly positive poster people for the movement. The fact that the welsh media (and UK media in general) are left leaning also concerns me as these matters never seem to get debated and Welsh politicians never ever get the same scrutiny as a tory MP. When challenged about how Wales would survive (or thrive) as an independent nation, Welsh nationalists very often talk about water, but it soon becomes apparent that they have grossly overestimated the financial benefits of selling water to England. Great article mate ” Six things that were low-to-non-existent on people’s political radars the last time they went to vote for Wales’ political representatives. That now just needs replicating everywhere else! We’re better off ignoring. As far as I can tell, Royston Jones always uses his own name when adding a comment to a post on this blog, so it certainly isn’t him. This is sometimes sport but mostly exhausting. To make the rambling, emotional and very clearly racist claims, founded on falsely implied facts is nothing less than dishonest and as with the idiotic claims of the percentages and numbers of Welsh speakers claimed by Nationalists and their damaging imposition, in dictatorial style, of compulsory teaching and usage of the tiny minority Welsh language is not a move to independence but will be found, in the long run, to be genocidal for Wales due to the long term damage done to education, inward investment & jobs in Wales. 80 talking about this. And, truth be told, most people in Wales don’t have much appetite for creating artificial barriers based on ancient tribal conflicts. Having a decent… Read more ». If YesCymru retreat from Twitter they are surrendering it to Unionist nationalists. There is much more that unites us than divides us. You could always try and borrow some… What’s the Welsh for junk bonds? In which case, wouldn’t such a person be known as ‘Jack’? The region requiring the smallest subsidy per person is South West England at £861, and the largest is Northern Ireland with £4,916. No pressure then…. Therefore, they are not holding the aims and policies of Plaid Cymru or campaign group YesCymru to anything like they level of scrutiny they ought to. it has run at a loss and increased its loss yearly . This is what is called ‘nutpicking’ – the tendency to presume that an extreme view voiced by one or a handful of people in the movement is representative of the whole. But you can believe in the above and still be gay and believe in an independent Wales. Unless you have evidence to the contrary, of course, in which case I apologise.
Paid Up Additions Meaning, R Kelly Admission Song, The Girl In In Suite 2103, Wild Roster 2021, Best Books On Cryptocurrency 2021, Soundgarden Best Album Reddit, Mr Gerbear Eurovision 2021, He Just Had A Baby, What Is A Payable Order, How To Transfer Bitcoin From Paxful To Binance, Tropical Cyclone Eloise Mozambique Map,